(February 19, 2015 at 12:45 pm)Surgenator Wrote:(February 19, 2015 at 6:43 am)Riketto Wrote: So, you got the evidence that God is not there to observe the rock and to mantain this external projection in his mind?And that's what I was referring to. You assumed god exist, then ask me how do I know god isn't observing god. Your assumption that god exist isn't valid. Hence, your question is pointless.
Let us see this evidence.
You are the one who make a claim not me.
I am asking people whether the universe can or can not exist without a mind.
This is not a claim or as you say an assumption.
And then i make a comment about your claim in which YOU say ............Yes,the universe can exist without a mind. Like a rock can exist without anyone observing it.
My comment to your comment say........So, you got the evidence that God is not there to observe the rock and to mantain this external projection in his mind?
This comment of mine once again is not a claim that God exist or is looking at the rock.
It is rather a question referring to your comment that the universe can exist without a mind.
Surely, hypothetically speaking a mind could also be Father Christmas or anybody else other than God.
In my answer i didn't claim that God is the one who look at the rock.
On the other hand you claim that the universe can exist without a mind.
How do you know that this is the case?
Have you got evidence that this is true?
So let us see your evidence.
