(March 8, 2015 at 4:08 pm)C4RM5 Wrote: Tubby in your opening statement you said that because a majority of atheists agreee with each other, atheist must therefore be correct. However a majority of people in a room could agree to throw someone out the window, arevthey therefore correct.
I'm not sure if it's a good example?
We would be saying that if 10 people decided to throw a person out of the window it would be OK if they had independantly come to that decision by sound reasoning and logic. I would be OK with that I suppose.
The comparison would be 10 people that already believed they should throw him out of the window but couldn't agree how to do it?
I don't know how to make your point seem relevant to be honest. My point is that atheists generally are in agreement in their lack of belief in god (at least). Christians believe in god but seldom seem to agree on what that actually means (by virtue of it being something that they largely construct in their own mind).
