Turning the tables on atheism

[Brian37]

Lets cut our Muslim friend here some slack, Islam isn't the only religion on the face of the planet. Nobody in antiquity of any religion worldwide had any clue of the nature of reality that we know today.

No one is picking on Islam. We’re pointing out his erroneous logic.

I wasn't arguing that. 

I was simply pointing out that every religion in the world has basically the same arguments based on the words you used "erroneous logic".