RE: Do you know WikiIslam ?
April 18, 2022 at 12:52 pm
(This post was last modified: April 18, 2022 at 12:54 pm by R00tKiT.)
(April 18, 2022 at 1:25 am)viocjit Wrote: I think you seriously need to study evolution theory because there wasn't a first homo sapiens as you claim.
What kind of drugs are you taking lately ?
I don't need to study anything to know that a finite collection of people contains its oldest individual. This is kindergaten logic.
The collection of all homo sapiens contains the oldest homo sapien. The first homo sapien = the oldest homo sapien. QED.
(April 18, 2022 at 1:25 am)viocjit Wrote: If Ahmed told a thing to Bilal (Youngest brother of Ahmed).
Bilal can involuntary deform what said Ahmed to him when he will speak to Tahseen (Wife of Bilal).
Tahseen will report Bilal sayings to Jamila (Oldest sister of Tahseen) without deform these but she will use others words with the same meaning.
Jamila will tell the sayings to another one and deforming these involuntary etc...
If you tell a thing to Andrew and tell the same thing to Beckie some years after your talk with Andrew.
You won't use the same words even if they had the same meanings.
What you will tell to each of them can be a bit different if you give more details to Beckie.
What you will tell to each of them will be a bit different if you say they were between 5 to 10 men to Andrew and between 6 to 15 men to Beckie.
Therefore they will tell a different story if they report what you said to them.
It takes serious brain damage to compare the sayings of a social reformer who claimed he communicates with God and managed to convince hundreds of thousands (in his lifetime) to the sayings of Ahmad and Jamila.
Martin Luther King said : "I have a dream". Do you think this simple utterance of 4 words will be deformed with time, given how well-known it is?
The same thing is true about the sayings of any social reformer, his sayings are repeated and studied by large crowds of people, implemented in legal systems, in school curriculums, etc. Muslim scholars devised an additional discipline called the science of hadiths to evaluate the chains of narrators. Any narrator should have a record of reproducing texts accurately from memory, and of taking his Islamic faith very seriously, which includes being morally upright and not distorting facts. Maybe the better question is how they can possibly miss what the prophet (who they believe is sent by God) have said..!
Hadiths are very easy to remember in Arabic (and to recognize!) and I can tell you very quickly (without being a scholar or even a sharia' student) whether a particular hadith is authentic or not.
And it also sounds you have a very distorted way of looking at lapses of time.. 14 centuries for example is just 20 successive individuals who lived for 70 years on average.
