(July 23, 2015 at 6:04 pm)Minimalist Wrote: Oh, please....now you're sounding like Randy. "My scholars say that your scholars are big poopy-heads."
Well you were the one who was praising Luxenberg as a scholar, and talking about his credibility and all, so don't cry when I say that most of the other scholars don't agree with his arguments.
Secondly, I was talking about scholarship as a whole - meaning both Muslim and non-Musilm scholars - on what they think about Luxenberg's work. I was explaining to you that there is a consensus amongst scholars that Luxenberg's arguments are flawed. That's not the same as saying that "my" scholars said so and so about "your" scholars. That is simply putting words in my mouth.
Thirdly, you know that I did post an explanation of why Luxenberg's work has been generally rejected, but you haven't directly addressed those points either.
