India Plate

[Deesse23]

Maybe dinosaur language?

Well, 3 things.  

1.   Many dinosaurs have anatomical features interpreted to support specialized vocalization. 

2.   One branch of dinosaurs is directly ancestral to birds, and likely possessed brains organized similarly to birds.

3.   Of all animals ever studied, babbler birds come closest to having a human like auditory language.  Closer than possessed by any extent primate.   https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/20...152230.htm


This doesn’t prove any dinosaurs had language precursors.    But if you were to ask me whether it is plausible that babbler like capability for language precursors may have existed in bird lineage all the way back to non-avian dinosaurs,  I would say nothing rules it out.

Obviously you dint get that me (and others) are simply mocking the OP for the utter stupidity of his arguments. The my posts about dinosaur was part of that.

Let me remind you of the OPs original claim:

Yes the ocean floor became the Himalayas which is a huge divide. But, it appears these peoples where already there on both sides with the ability of complex language.

"People", not dinosaurs, not trilobites, not bird or any other animal that "communicates" by whatever means. Peo.ple. with com.plex.lan.guage.

Got it?

[Gawdzilla Sama]

[Anomalocaris]

Well, 3 things.  

1.   Many dinosaurs have anatomical features interpreted to support specialized vocalization. 

2.   One branch of dinosaurs is directly ancestral to birds, and likely possessed brains organized similarly to birds.

3.   Of all animals ever studied, babbler birds come closest to having a human like auditory language.  Closer than possessed by any extent primate.   https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/20...152230.htm


This doesn’t prove any dinosaurs had language precursors.    But if you were to ask me whether it is plausible that babbler like capability for language precursors may have existed in bird lineage all the way back to non-avian dinosaurs,  I would say nothing rules it out.

Obviously you dint get that me (and others) are simply mocking the OP for the utter stupidity of his arguments. The my posts about dinosaur was part of that.

Let me remind you of the OPs original claim:

Yes the ocean floor became the Himalayas which is a huge divide. But, it appears these peoples where already there on both sides with the ability of complex language.

"People", not dinosaurs, not trilobites, not bird or any other animal that "communicates" by whatever means. Peo.ple. with com.plex.lan.guage.

Got it?

Hey, dinosaurs are people too!

---

I know when Pangea assembled and when it fragmented.   The question is what level of communication sophistication are animals of that era capable of, and at what level of sophistication would we call the communication language.

LOL. They were animals with no capacity for language. Give it a rest.

When Donald trump, his spawns, senate republicans and fox talking heads have all been observed to mimic the use of language,  how can you really be sure much more advanced quadrupeds like salamanders and dinosaurs won’t have the ability to actually use languages?

[Gawdzilla Sama]

When Donald trump, his spawns, senate republicans and fox talking heads have all been observed to mimic the use of language,  how can you really be sure much more advanced quadrupeds like salamanders and dinosaurs won’t have the ability to actually use languages?

You are being silly.

[Haipule]

Good to hear from you Haipule.
How's the weather? :-)

Thank you Little Lunch! Perfect as always. How you stay?

[Little lunch]

Good to hear from you Haipule.
How's the weather? :-)

Thank you Little Lunch! Perfect as always. How you stay?

Yeah, not bad.
I wish I was as close to the beach as you of course. :-)

[chimp3]

Aloha AF:

Puzzle: No doubt the India Plate broke off from Africa and Madagascar and eventually smashed into South Asia absorbing some islands on the way. The geology and minerology of the India Plate is radically different than the Eurasian Plate but similar to Africa and Madagascar--but when did they collide? Also radically different is the ethnicity and the cultural differences between the people of India and South Asia to this day. It appears to me that the people of India did not migrate there but where migrated there through plate tectonics.

Now, if I establish that a man is man only because of the ability of complex language. Then man, with the ability of complex language, according to most, is about 50,000yrs old.

Therefore, the people of the India Plate, who went for a ride, and the people of the Eurasian plate, both must of had the ability of complex language at the time the plates collided making it much later than the 40M years ago that current geologic studies suggest.

That is not smarter than a Fifth grader,

[downbeatplumb]

Obviously you dint get that me (and others) are simply mocking the OP for the utter stupidity of his arguments. The my posts about dinosaur was part of that.

Let me remind you of the OPs original claim:
"People", not dinosaurs, not trilobites, not bird or any other animal that "communicates" by whatever means. Peo.ple. with com.plex.lan.guage.

Got it?

Hey, dinosaurs are people too!

---

LOL. They were animals with no capacity for language. Give it a rest.

When Donald trump, his spawns, senate republicans and fox talking heads have all been observed to mimic the use of language,  how can you really be sure much more advanced quadrupeds like salamanders and dinosaurs won’t have the ability to actually use languages?

NOT THE MOMMA.

[Haipule]

Thank you Little Lunch! Perfect as always. How you stay?

Yeah, not bad.
I wish I was as close to the beach as you of course. :-)

They just started opening the beach to beach goers yesterday. Before that it was a $5,000 fine. Restaurants are closed and travel is banned and all the resorts are closed. There are no tourists which is cool but nothing to do but drink. So I'm cool! Any tourist that does make one of the few flights is forced to stay in there room for a 14 day quarantine. If they get caught leaving their room, they are arrested, jailed and fined or shipped back. There is no reason to come here anyway.

---

Only from the mind of Haipule: be very afraid!

The earth is approximately 4.5Byrs old. It has been subjected to much chaos and destruction with fits and starts followed by floods, snowballs, glaciers, on and on, making geology tough.

At one time dinosaurs roamed a different earth and were destroyed. Then came mammals. Also a different earth, also eventually destroyed.

(You may want to stop here) Because of the massive size of some of those creatures, that different earth must of been smaller, without an ocean, with less gravitational effect. And if those massive creatures where cold blooded, there must have been a lens of water above making the whole earth a similar temperature without weather. 

50.000yrs ago, Smaller Earth was in a snowball state frozen without light or heat. Once melted, and the waters separated again, flowers showed up, as well as man with the ability of complex language never known before. The water above compressing the air, created a hyperbaric chamber by which man lived much, much longer.

During that small earth pre-flood time, man, with the ability of complex language, walked to India and Australia as there was no ocean. 

Then, at some point, the water above fell like rain for several days and the super heated water from inside came up allowing cool water back in causing the earth to break apart and expand as the water raised creating the ocean and our present size earth. The peoples of India and Australia found themselves on Islands and we're back to the OP.


Makes more sense then supercontinent and superocean! And that, in spite of the stirred up mess called "Geology".

[The Grand Nudger]

For certain values of sense.