Greek cosmology

[SeniorCitizen]

There were Greek philosophers who, several hundred years BC, speculated as to whether the stars were suns like ours, but very far away, with inhabited planets going round them.

[Belacqua]

There were Greek philosophers who, several hundred years BC, speculated as to whether the stars were suns like ours, but very far away, with inhabited planets going round them.

It's always amazing to me how much they were able to figure out, without modern methods. And without coffee!

Bishop Nicholas of Cusa, almost 100 years before Galileo, suggested that the universe is infinite, that the earth is not the center, and that aliens out there might be looking back at us. We owe a lot to these creative thinkers. 

Here is a good, careful, propaganda-free blog that traces the history of these issues:

https://thonyc.wordpress.com/

[Gawdzilla Sama]

There were Greek philosophers who, several hundred years BC, speculated as to whether the stars were suns like ours, but very far away, with inhabited planets going round them.

And there were dozens of competing theories as well.

[Anomalocaris]

There were Greek philosophers who, several hundred years BC, speculated as to whether the stars were suns like ours, but very far away, with inhabited planets going round them.

It's always amazing to me how much they were able to figure out, without modern methods. And without coffee!

Bishop Nicholas of Cusa, almost 100 years before Galileo, suggested that the universe is infinite, that the earth is not the center, and that aliens out there might be looking back at us. We owe a lot to these creative thinkers. 

Here is a good, careful, propaganda-free blog that traces the history of these issues:

https://thonyc.wordpress.com/

You are too easily amazed.


The Greek who thought that stars were suns very far away was no more insightful than the Greek who thought stars are what god put up there to commemorate episodes from Greek mythology.     Neither of them figured out anything.   Both of them guessed without evidence or a priori insight.    The one that happen to get it right by chance does not thereby deserve ex post attribution of insight.


This is different from the Greeks who figured out earth is round,  because erastothenes and Aristotle actually derived genuine insight using actual evidence.

[no one]

I hear these Greeks had a particular interest in Uranus.