Why would God?

[Neo-Scholastic]

You have as much as admitted that you have a closed mind. You ask for evidence then dismiss it because it does not conform to your worldview.

again.. evidence for supernatural. . Never in court.. I live on earth.. where u from?

You are taking the metaphor too seriously. What qualifies as "supernatural" is the question at hand. But you have already made up your mind to exclude certain phenomena, like your sister's experience, because it challenges your assumptions about how the world should, in your opinion, be.

[Esquilax]

So the testimony of a reliable witness is not considered evidence? I'd like to see you try justifying that one in a court of law.

Just so long as you do the reverse: how many courts would accept testimony that involves magic, regardless of how otherwise reliable the witness is? More likely, they'd conclude that the witness is mistaken or less reliable than they first appear.

What's more likely: that somebody had an experience that violates everything we know to be true about the world, or that someone made a mistake?

[The Reality Salesman01]

Chad has been telling me that it actually doesn't violate anything you believe to be true about the world so long as you maintain that there could be a quantum explanation for it. As long as you think there could be a quantum explanation for something, anything is possible, and equally valid as anything contradicting that is demonstrable. I'm not quite sure why it makes sense yet, but he seems to be pretty sure that it does.

[ThomM]

Why would god make so many mistakes if he is the all powerful creator?
He made humans and everything and gave us all sin? Why?
He made all humans, so he made some gay. Why does he frown upon what he made?
He knows all, so wouldn’t he know that we would torture and kill his “son”?
He made humans so why did his son have to be born and not created?
Why would god make the devil just to have fun taunting and tempting us?


Yea I think to much,but never understood these.

Sin is defined as being an offense against the morality of a god - if YOU look at the Bible - the god has no morals at all -and actually murdered at will. SO sin does not exist -

WE have not a single word that can be proven to have been the thought of or having come from a god - so even if a god did create all humans - which is nonsense itself - NO ONE can prove he is for or against gays.

THE statements on the cross - as claimed in the bible - are indeed one example of why the claim of the god to be all knowing simply cannot be considered real. The further claim of FREE WILL - means that a human MUST have the ability to choose something the god did not know - or the will is not free. IF all you can do is what the god already knows - then there is no free will at all - for anyone - even the god.

THe MYTH of the christ is a human created bunch of nonsense - based on lots of earlier myths and legends of other religions. WHat is clear - is that whoever made up the myth of the christ failed to actually read the Old Testament first - since the messiah prophecies could NOT have been fullfilled by the christ.


As far as the God and the Devil - if you really follow the story - they are one and the same. If there is only one creator - then that creator must be the ultimate evil as well as the ultimate good - still another problem for monotheisms. Note - the myth of the devil is quite different between the old and new testaments.

[Neo-Scholastic]

Wrong thread...

[truthBtold]

U have already fooled urself..

[kılıç_mehmet]

Why would god make so many mistakes if he is the all powerful creator?
He made humans and everything and gave us all sin? Why?
He made all humans, so he made some gay. Why does he frown upon what he made?
He knows all, so wouldn’t he know that we would torture and kill his “son”?
He made humans so why did his son have to be born and not created?
Why would god make the devil just to have fun taunting and tempting us?


Yea I think to much,but never understood these.

You can ask your questions when you stand tall before the man, then.

[StoryBook]

You can ask your questions when you stand tall before the man, then.

What man?

[Severan]

Why would god make so many mistakes if he is the all powerful creator?
He made humans and everything and gave us all sin? Why?
He made all humans, so he made some gay. Why does he frown upon what he made?
He knows all, so wouldn’t he know that we would torture and kill his “son”?
He made humans so why did his son have to be born and not created?
Why would god make the devil just to have fun taunting and tempting us?


Yea I think to much,but never understood these.

You can ask your questions when you stand tall before the man, then.

You can stand tall before Allah, Zeus, Santa clause, and Casper the friendly ghost. Every piece of faith is the same.

Please grow the fuck up, get a brain, think for yourself, and realize that faith is blind belief with no evidence.

(Santa is actually less blind then believing in a deity. Presents are evidence for the man. God has no evidence.)