(January 24, 2016 at 4:29 pm)athrock Wrote:(January 24, 2016 at 1:57 pm)Mr.wizard Wrote: So let me get this straight, there is an all powerful god who gives an objective morality that we don't know about, gives commands that contradicts it, gives us free will to subjectively make our own moral decisions, then sits and waits to punish us for not getting it right?
Uh...no?
If He "gives an objective morality" then how could we not know about it? We would have had to receive it.
He has given no commands that contradict His own morality.
He has given us free will.
And yes, he will ultimately judge and punish those who choose poorly.
But you (and those reading this thread) are not completely ignorant of all this since you have deigned to make the case you posted above.
So, it won't be like you didn't know...
Ah so if we are programmed with this objective morality doesn't that violate our free will? We are not free to determine right from wrong god has already done it for us.
