Christoid Logic

[robvalue]

To the opening post:

Yes, pretty much every conversation I've ever had ends up with "God is magic".  

This is true.

The properties that define invisible "God" are constantly being shifted, altered, and made up on the fly at any given moment. I used to say "Hey! You can't do that! You can't just change the specifics regarding the nature of your god, mid-discussion." 

I've since come to accept that theists can very well do this; There simply aren't any limits in the land of make-believe.

That's it, exactly. When the whole thing is made up and not real, you can't do it "wrong". It can be internally consistent, or not. And when something isn't real, and so never comes under any sort of actual scrutiny, it can get away with being inconsistent.