(July 28, 2016 at 3:50 pm)RozKek Wrote:
And it doesn't matter whether you like it or not, whether it's an interesting view of reality, if it's true it's true. And when you evaluate and something seems good to your nature even the process of that evaluation isn't ultimately your decision, it was either partly random or bound to happen exactly the way it happened.
Well then, if you agree that you cannot break the causal chain, problem solved. All your intentions, actions, desires and such are a part of the causal chain and you cannot do anything to do otherwise but you can imagine different things to do. However even those imaginations i.e what you'll imagine would also be a part of that causal chain, in other words not under your control ultimately speaking.
I gather, from your post, and a number of posts from others, that what is being expounded on here, is that choices are entirely a mechanistic process brought about by physical forces within the brain. That given X in you will get Y out (with a very complicated equation in between). Wouldn't this also apply to any logic or rational you are using to determine this? If what you are saying is true, then it would seem that you also have to free will to say whether yours or benny's logic is right or wrong. Or that you can say it, but have no way to determine if one is more correct than the other. Would you agree?