The "Cultural Context" Excuse

[Thumpalumpacus]

So you're fine with calling collective punishment just?

In the case of Noah, God warned them of the flood for 120 years before it happened.

In the case of Sodom and Gomorrah God said he would spare the city if he could find just 10 righteous people living there.

But Huggy, we're talking about women here, don't you remember? That was the specific example of collective punishment that was bruited. Why are you arguing the "justice" of other examples? We can get into those later, sure. But address this point in its own, ahem, context.

Do you consider the collective punishment of women for Eve's "sin" just, or not? Explain why.

I notice you still haven't answered my other question yet ... must not want to hear me answer yours much, I gather.