Richard Carrier - The Hero Savior Analogy

[Pat Mustard]

I'm sorry, of what, that stories of magical men are mythical?  Or that the story of this particular magic man is mythical?  Which of those two statements would you disagree with most strenuously?

I thought that we where talking about The position of Jesus as a myth.  And I am looking for whatever position you are putting forth....  but from your question, I gather, that your position is not based on logic and reason, or any evidence, rather than pre-supposing  the conclusion in the premise.

Rhythm: Showing Jesus as being able to peform magic is reason enough to consider him a mythical creation.
Roadrunner: Y u no talk about Jesus being a myth?

Seriously Roadrunner, you should read your opposite number's comment before giving out to him about it.