On Moral Authorities

[Edwardo Piet]

When you say it could be "neither" you are agreeing with me that it's a false dichotomy.

Negative. You were galaxies away from explicating how it's neither. Let me demonstrate: option d, squirrels, just because. Accept it or accept you're wrong.

You said it could be "neither". That's all I said, that it could be neither.

I don't have to explain logically why it's neither I never said it was.

YOU ARE JOKING?! Lucky for you I'm on my phone right now and cannot be bothered to quote every single time you kept parroting 'neither'.

My answer was "neither". I can give that answer because it's not a true dichotomy. I never said it it necessarily was neither. It's neither because there are no gods.

That was your own strawman of me.

Bull-fucking-shit. This is too rich.

It was. My answer is "neither", the fact that I can give that answer demonstrates that the dichotomy is false.

So it took this long for you to admit I was right, basically. And you still haven't admitted I'm right explicitly, you've only done it implicitly, and you're probably going to continue to double down on why it's not a false dichotomy, according to you, despite just now implicitly agreeing that it is one.

Hopeless.

A false dichotomy is a dichotomy where "neither" can be given as answer.
I said it was a false dichotomy.
You admitted that "neither" can be given as an answer.
Thereby you admitted that I was right.

In reality, the only one embarrassing themselves here is you. Anyone who thinks I'm embarrassing myself is just one more person who can't grasp my logic.

Your brand of logic reeks of falsities. Not interested.

There is no "brand" of logic, there's contradictory and non-contradictory logic. You are being contradictory because you're insisting the dilemma we are discussing is not a false dichotomy at the same time as admitting that it is.

Here's my own argument from authority to counteract your bullshit about Plato, seen as you like your fallacies so much:

“Do not fear to be eccentric in opinion, for every opinion now accepted was once eccentric.”
― Bertrand Russell

Cool.

Yes I am.