Serious Problems with Atheism

[Mister Agenda]

Ah ok we are resorting to abuse, yes that's typical of Atheists, seen it all before, nothing wrong with abuse in a Universe with No good or evil right?

Even if that were true and not simply a pathetic attempt to poison the well, so what? You expect that from us, you think it's what we believe and how we behave. So why complain about it?

Yeah, implicit in the rebuke is the idea that we're the kind of people who would feel bad if we realized we were abusing someone; as an insult it kind of refutes itself: the only reason to use it is to provoke us to feel bad about what we've done, but it states that we are not the sort of people who see anything wrong with what we've done. There's certainly a disconnect between the premise and the actual insult.