Tooth Fairy Bullshit

[Cephus]

Because those are all subjective questions. 

If they are, are you living your life consistent with the logical conclusions of that opinion? Seems to me that a lot of AF members have rejected Christianity yet still try to justify their belief that human equality and personal autonomy are valid secular moral principles. Of course atheists can be good without god, but they cannot logically claim to be good without referencing some transcendent source of the good.

That's totally irrelevant.  I pointed out to you why one question is valid and the other is not and you're ignoring that and trying to end-run around it. Gods have not been demonstrated to be objectively real.  Period.  Desperately trying to spin your way out of that reality is ridiculous.  But then again, you have an imaginary friend, I suppose we can't be too surprised.