Quote:no one seems to be taking this guy too seriously and seem to sort of act as if his arguments are just nonsense automatically without really giving them a decent look.
You're quite wrong there. I was raised catholic and decided that it was just as stupid as the jews and moslems and hindus and all the other faiths which catholicism TOLD ME WERE WRONG.
They took their best shot with me and I rejected them and their god-based arguments because at the end of the day their god is no more real than any one else's god. And, btw, that was before we knew that they were sodomizing children on an institutional basis and having their hierarchy cover up the crimes.
Why are you having trouble understanding that? You say you are dealing with a guy who is making faith based arguments and you wonder why a room full of atheists is having trouble with it?