See, I'm a hedonist. But I identify as a hedonist. I don't say "emotionally are intrinsically good and bad" and then declare victory.
Sure, TD may have at least tried to give arguments afterwards. But she still claims that emotions are intrinsically good and bad is her only premise, as far as I am aware (and maybe some other one about emotional value judgements, but that still gets her nowhere) but that (those) premise(s) is (are) insufficient.
Sure, TD may have at least tried to give arguments afterwards. But she still claims that emotions are intrinsically good and bad is her only premise, as far as I am aware (and maybe some other one about emotional value judgements, but that still gets her nowhere) but that (those) premise(s) is (are) insufficient.