Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic

[Neo-Scholastic]

Side note: I found an article here 

Thank you for that link. Sounds like she's spent some time on AF. She sure summed up the annoying 90% of AF.

The thing is, when talking to some theists, they are obviously talking about a god which does not compare to pagan deities. Yet, for the most part--when speaking to a colloquial Christian, for instance, they are obviously not talking about the god of the philosophers.

Not necessarily. People who talk about the sun rising in the East still know that the Earth actually resolves. In the back of their minds most Christians know that it all goes back to Exodus 3:14 and John 1:1 even when talking about God in more anthropomorphic ways and even if they don't know the exact theology.