Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic

[Mister Agenda]

The Christian god Yahweh is also derived from previously held concepts.  So can he too be reasonably dismissed as being real.  If so, then I concede defeat (to you at least).  If, however, you still hold that God exists then I still maintain that Odin is real.  After all I can simply argue that the similarities from other religions are based in part truth, and part the work of the trickster god and shapeshifter Loki. 

This discussion isn't about Yahweh, now is it? In the other thread I clearly stated that I would provide evidence for God if someone provided evidence against and well see who had the most for and against... no one took me up on it.

It doesn't matter who has the most evidence. It matters who has the best evidence.

---

So you have a scientifically vetted photo of god? hahahahahahaha

Laugh it up, it's not like I haven't already posted it but then you wouldn't know this since you're a straight up newb.

I remember that. It was both sad and laughable that anyone would consider it evidence of anything but bad lighting, poor photography, and desperately motivated 'reasoning'.

---

You don't get it, the point is can you provide the same for Odin?

Btw if you were an eye witness then you'd have no choice but to be a believer... Isn't that what you guys say? If you saw evidence you'd believe?

Are you saying that the proper response to a claim where you find the evidence offered to support it insufficient to justify acceptance is to withhold belief?