Another hypothetical for theists.

[Neo-Scholastic]

-all of the above exists regardless of whether or not god exists.

Still, though, for all of the above "goods".....Jeff was somehow incapable of making any of them unless he made dysentery, as well....allegedly.

You can't have moral agency unless you also have ebola.  

Repeating a logical fallacy does make it valid and just makes you look foolish. It remains an argument from incredulity.