Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic

[RoadRunner79]

By a show of hands, if I said that an elephant suddenly appeared in my back yard (like poof)  without reason.  How many would consider that plausible?

*sigh*

It’s like the last 15 pages never happened and we have to start all over.  I imagine this is why atheists get bored with debating after a while.

I admit, that I was having a bit of fun there, and I didn't expect that anyone would agree with that or that this represents their position. But if we get rid of the principle of sufficient reason, then why not? If things can begin to exist without cause, then what would limit an elephant from appearing without cause? Given enough time and chance, isn't anything possible?