They get their arses kicked by the "Klingons" and then have the brilliant idea to beam a torpedo warhead onto a dead "Klingon" being tractored aboard the enemy ship.
Good so far.
The torpedo goes off disabling the "klingon" ship.
Good.
Then they beam the Captain and the 1st officer aboard the enemy ship. Not an assault team: The most experienced and high ranking officers on their ship.
Then they beam the survivor back and abandon ship. They don't beam more warheads aboard the one remaining enemy shipband finish it off...
Good so far.
The torpedo goes off disabling the "klingon" ship.
Good.
Then they beam the Captain and the 1st officer aboard the enemy ship. Not an assault team: The most experienced and high ranking officers on their ship.
Then they beam the survivor back and abandon ship. They don't beam more warheads aboard the one remaining enemy shipband finish it off...
Playing Cluedo with my mum while I was at Uni:
"You did WHAT? With WHO? WHERE???"