(November 22, 2021 at 4:03 pm)Klorophyll Wrote:(November 22, 2021 at 3:36 pm)Rahn127 Wrote: Brooke, back in 1860 Wild Bill Hickok was known as a fairly good shot with a rifle. My grandfather told me stories that had been passed down from his grandfather's grandfather. The story was about how my great ancestor was in a shootout with Wild Bill. My great ancestor was only 17 at the time and he thought he was the best shot in the world.
He went up against Wild Bill and found out how wrong he was.
Wild Bill shot him dead and this was before he had taken a wife or had any children. They buried him in a shallow grave.
A few days later, family went to put flowers on the grave and found it empty. The body was gone. He had been resurrected some would say.
My family line is proof of that resurrection. If he hadn't come back to life, none of my ancestors would have been born.
Brooke, can you tell me what is wrong with believing that this story is factual and true ?
The principle of credulity actually dictates that we should believe you, until we are presented with evidence that you are making this up.
Because otherwise, if we were to accept Hume's criticism of miracles (that someone reporting events mistakenly is always more probable than that the laws of the universe were suspended for them) we are ruling out miracles a priori, it's question-begging.
Kloro, I know that you know what is intrinsically wrong with this story that I presented to everyone.
It's unbelievable for many reasons and you know this, but you also know that it's the same kind of unbelievable story that your religion absolutely begs for you to believe without question.
Insanity - Doing the same thing over and over again, expecting a different result
