@Skeptic201
As I said, Dr. Craig, if he was sincere (and, you, too), could bring this matter to the attention of the APS. Apparently, Dr. Craig is of the opinion that eternal, beginningless models of cosmology are intrinsically flawed. If so, one must wonder what the Nobel committee was thinking when they awarded Sir Roger Penrose the Nobel Prize in physics??
Of course, Dr. Craig is absolutely correct when he claims that one cannot "count" one's way to infinity, and, by Craig's reasoning, our Universe must be finite, not only in time but also in volume. But, yet, our Universe, per the BGV theorem, is expanding, which means that "the increase in distance between any two given gravitationally unbound parts of the observable universe with time." (Wikipedia, Expansion of the universe) And, yet, what is the Universe, per Dr. Craig, expanding "into"? "Nothing"? If Dr. Craig is going to claim that actual infinites cannot exist in Nature, then how can our Universe be finite without a spatial center? Please explain that one. And, if our Universe is finite, where's its surface or edge?? Explain that.
If you live by Science, that's fine. Just be honest about it.
As I said, Dr. Craig, if he was sincere (and, you, too), could bring this matter to the attention of the APS. Apparently, Dr. Craig is of the opinion that eternal, beginningless models of cosmology are intrinsically flawed. If so, one must wonder what the Nobel committee was thinking when they awarded Sir Roger Penrose the Nobel Prize in physics??
Of course, Dr. Craig is absolutely correct when he claims that one cannot "count" one's way to infinity, and, by Craig's reasoning, our Universe must be finite, not only in time but also in volume. But, yet, our Universe, per the BGV theorem, is expanding, which means that "the increase in distance between any two given gravitationally unbound parts of the observable universe with time." (Wikipedia, Expansion of the universe) And, yet, what is the Universe, per Dr. Craig, expanding "into"? "Nothing"? If Dr. Craig is going to claim that actual infinites cannot exist in Nature, then how can our Universe be finite without a spatial center? Please explain that one. And, if our Universe is finite, where's its surface or edge?? Explain that.
If you live by Science, that's fine. Just be honest about it.
