RE: Good exists - a Catholic comments
August 19, 2023 at 10:33 am
(This post was last modified: August 19, 2023 at 11:22 am by Bucky Ball.)
Barry
Typical religitard fundamental error.
Science proves no such thing.
1. The problem with this ignorance is that there WAS NO MATERIAL WORLD until it already existed.
You cannot generalize about what was before the material world from how you think a material world works now.
You know absolutely nothing about the environment your gods live in / BEFORE the material world.
Science in a world that already exists cannot prove anything about the environment from which the material world came from, when there WAS NO material world.
Very simple basic logic.
2. Science knows about how 5 % of this universe works. We are just beginning to understand many things including black holes. 95 % of this universe is Dark Energy and Dark Matter.
You don't know enough to make any generalizations until they are understood.
3. This ignorant argument does not lead to a god. An omnipotent deity could have created evil robot universe makers whose job it is to make universes where innocent children get molested and die every day from cancers.
It is a well known fact (well not to ignorant religionists) that the laws of physics "break down at a singularity", and if the Big Bang was one, which some cosmologists think may be true,
even then, in this material world, causation and space-time (we know of no "time" separate from space) would not operate as we know of it.
https://bigthink.com/starts-with-a-bang/...ome%20real.
"Whoever said, “You can’t get something from nothing” must never have learned quantum physics. As long as you have empty space — the ultimate in physical nothingness — simply manipulating it in the right way will inevitably cause something to emerge. Collide two particles in the abyss of empty space, and sometimes additional particle-antiparticle pairs emerge. Take a meson and try to rip the quark away from the antiquark, and a new set of particle-antiparticle pairs will get pulled out of the empty space between them. And in theory, a strong enough electromagnetic field can rip particles and antiparticles out of the vacuum itself, even without any initial particles or antiparticles at all."
Quote:So how did the world begin?
My answer is that science proves nothing can be created from nothing in our material world, so the only explanation is that something external created the world.
Typical religitard fundamental error.
Science proves no such thing.
1. The problem with this ignorance is that there WAS NO MATERIAL WORLD until it already existed.
You cannot generalize about what was before the material world from how you think a material world works now.
You know absolutely nothing about the environment your gods live in / BEFORE the material world.
Science in a world that already exists cannot prove anything about the environment from which the material world came from, when there WAS NO material world.
Very simple basic logic.
2. Science knows about how 5 % of this universe works. We are just beginning to understand many things including black holes. 95 % of this universe is Dark Energy and Dark Matter.
You don't know enough to make any generalizations until they are understood.
3. This ignorant argument does not lead to a god. An omnipotent deity could have created evil robot universe makers whose job it is to make universes where innocent children get molested and die every day from cancers.
It is a well known fact (well not to ignorant religionists) that the laws of physics "break down at a singularity", and if the Big Bang was one, which some cosmologists think may be true,
even then, in this material world, causation and space-time (we know of no "time" separate from space) would not operate as we know of it.
https://bigthink.com/starts-with-a-bang/...ome%20real.
"Whoever said, “You can’t get something from nothing” must never have learned quantum physics. As long as you have empty space — the ultimate in physical nothingness — simply manipulating it in the right way will inevitably cause something to emerge. Collide two particles in the abyss of empty space, and sometimes additional particle-antiparticle pairs emerge. Take a meson and try to rip the quark away from the antiquark, and a new set of particle-antiparticle pairs will get pulled out of the empty space between them. And in theory, a strong enough electromagnetic field can rip particles and antiparticles out of the vacuum itself, even without any initial particles or antiparticles at all."
Every religion is true one way or another. It is true when understood metaphorically. But when it gets stuck in its own metaphors, interpreting them as facts, then you are in trouble. - Joseph Campbell 
Militant Atheist Commie Evolutionist
Militant Atheist Commie Evolutionist
