Good exists - a Catholic comments

[Thumpalumpacus]

No, but unless you've observed how every giraffe came into existence, then what are you basing your claim that it hasn't happened on?

Giraffes come into this world a certain way. We know this because we have observed giraffes coming into this world in that certain way. We know they do not pop into existence out of nowhere. We do not need to have observed the birth of every giraffe to know all of this.

You said "it's never happened".

Now we see that this is your assumption. A reasonable one, to be sure.

What's revealing is your refusal to admit that this is your assumption. It speaks to your intellectual integrity, such as it is.