(January 8, 2012 at 2:09 am)chipan Wrote: well then i correct myself and say that you said i'm mostly right. it's more than they gave me saying i'm all wrong.
That wasn't what I said at all. You were right about the the basics behind C14 dating. The underlying argument (that it is inaccurate, and the reasons you gave) were wrong. As that's what you based your argument on, I'd have a hard time saying your argument was "mostly right".
In other words, with respect to the elements of your post that were not in contention, you were correct. Those related to your argument on the inaccuracy of C14 dating were wrong. I'd call that mostly wrong, with respect to the argument of inaccuracy.
Being wrong on that point means your argument falls on it's face.