That is what she said. Her beliefs are as good as any, therefore they are worthless.
1. My beliefs are as good as any.
2. If my beliefs are as good as any, they are as good as none.
3. My beliefs are as good as none (MP 1,2)
4. If my beliefs are as good as none, they are nihilistic
5. My beliefs are nihilistic (MP 3,4)
Where does this break down?
1. My beliefs are as good as any.
2. If my beliefs are as good as any, they are as good as none.
3. My beliefs are as good as none (MP 1,2)
4. If my beliefs are as good as none, they are nihilistic
5. My beliefs are nihilistic (MP 3,4)
Where does this break down?