RE: Show me your proof
April 7, 2013 at 8:37 am
(This post was last modified: April 7, 2013 at 8:37 am by Mystic.)
Mr_Drew, it doesn't make sense to agree on the first premise, also agree that eternal praiseworthiness is not earned, and then reject the conclusion.
You agreed earning praiseworthiness is more worthy than not.
You agreed eternal praiseworthiness is not earned.
The conclusion necessarily follows from that.
So which of these two premises do you disagree with? Because, from your post, it seemed you agreed with both, but just disliked the conclusion and opposed that. I dislike the conclusion as well, but I don't oppose it, because it seems true to me.
You agreed earning praiseworthiness is more worthy than not.
You agreed eternal praiseworthiness is not earned.
The conclusion necessarily follows from that.
So which of these two premises do you disagree with? Because, from your post, it seemed you agreed with both, but just disliked the conclusion and opposed that. I dislike the conclusion as well, but I don't oppose it, because it seems true to me.
