Quote:Morality does not require a god. Plain and simple. You have not even explained how morality would require a god, because as far as I can discern you are merely bombarding us with nonsensical word salad.
You are clearly as charming as your photo. here's the argument, not that I think you are very interested in addressing it, preferring as you do to merely assert.
1.Morality instructs/favours/commands
2.Only an agent can instruct/favour/command
3.Morality is an agent
That’s the first step. Obviously this leaves open that morality might be us, our communities, or whatever.
Next step.
1.Morality’s instructions confer reasons to comply whatever of the interests of those to whom they apply. (So, if morality truly does instruct you not to kill you thereby have reason not to kill even if you really, really want to.)
2.Only the commands/instructions/favourings of a supernatural agent who controls our fate in an afterlife would confer reasons to all to whom they are applied.
3.Therefore morality’s instructions are the commands/instructions/favourings of a supernatural agent of the kind described in 2.
