(July 10, 2013 at 1:09 pm)genkaus Wrote:(July 10, 2013 at 1:05 pm)Inigo Wrote: I didn't define it as 'presupposing god'. I defined it as 'instructions and favourings that have inescapable rational authority'. Idiot.
And given that you refer to that external inescapable rational authority as god - I guess you are presupposing it.
No, I refer to instructions that have inescapable rational authority as 'moral' instructions. I have argued that only the instructions of a god would have those features and therefore that morality presupposes a god.
You must either show me to be mistaken about that or else make sure that you never use the term 'morality' to refer to instructions that have inescapable rational authority. Nothing stops you doing that and I don't mind in the least if you do.