Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 17, 2026, 1:29 pm

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Free will Argument against Divine Providence
#74
RE: Free will Argument against Divine Providence
(August 9, 2013 at 10:27 am)genkaus Wrote: The reason why your test itself is invalid is as follows:

Your first requirement is that the monist position should prove that any physical system actually experiences the way you do when you wake up in the morning. However, the basic premise of physical monism is that everything is a physical system - including you, me and the rest of the humanity. Which means, you yourself are the example of a physical system that experiences the way you do. Which is why this argument is
a non-starter. The only way to counter this argument is by the assumption that "you" are more than a physical system. Which is basically disagreeing with premise of physical monism, i.e. assuming that "not everything is a physical system" and using that assumption to "disprove" physical monism.
When you start positing that properties which cannot be mutually observed or directly measured are "physical," then you've just redefined the word "physical." But if you're allowing this redefinition, you could also expand it to include God, fairies, the invisible pinkness of IPU and every OTHER entity or property which cannot be mutually observed or directly measured.
Quote:Similarly, your second criteria assumes that the dualist definition of mind or free-will is the "correct" definition and therefore, any operational definition of mind is equivalent to begging the question. But, this assumption is incorrect, which you'd realize if you actually took time to study the different views on the philosophy of mind. The most comprehensive and generic definitions of "mind" or "will" are philosophically neutral - they do not imply or favor a particular worldview such as dualism or monism. They are as applicable within monist context as they are within dualist one, though with quite different implications. However, the change in implications does not mean that the particular monist philosopher is redefining the word to avoid philosophical issues. And this is something you'd realize if you actually tried to understand how the word is used within different physicalist viewpoints.
The "correct" definition of mind is "the subjective experience of sensation and ideas" or something like that; it's a label for sentience. Now, you could define mind as brain function, but then what word will we use for "the subjective experience of sensation and ideas?" Let's say we call it "boobledyboo." You and I both know what will happen next: you will say, "boobledyboo is just brain function, and you can't prove otherwise!" But this ignores what most people really care about when they distinguish mind from body: whatever theory or world view you want to talk about, I do in fact wake up and become aware of my mind. And this mind is subjective, and is not objective; forcing it to take an objective meaning is goofy. The existence of the subjective stance is a brute fact, and cannot be defined away, not because of any particular position, but because we need a word to use as a label for that particular brute fact.

So let me ask you this: what are the criteria by which you (or ANY of the models, views or theories you keep telling me I'm ignorant of, but refuse to introduce into the discussion) determine something is "physical?" Let me guess: "Physical means any material, energy, or property which exists," right? Tongue
Reply



Messages In This Thread
RE: Free will Argument against Divine Providence - by bennyboy - August 9, 2013 at 5:24 pm

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  An Argument Against Determinism Disagreeable 32 6825 March 13, 2026 at 9:11 pm
Last Post: Disagreeable
  The Kalam Cosmological Argument Disagreeable 123 34611 December 15, 2024 at 6:11 pm
Last Post: BrianSoddingBoru4
  The classic ontological argument Modern Atheism 20 5685 October 3, 2024 at 12:45 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  The modal ontological argument for God Disagreeable 29 8556 August 10, 2024 at 8:57 pm
Last Post: MetisX
  Do you believe in free will? Disagreeable 37 9287 August 4, 2024 at 7:15 am
Last Post: Disagreeable
  The argument from degree LinuxGal 9 3054 January 1, 2023 at 12:14 am
Last Post: The Architect Of Fate
  Understanding the rudiment has much to give helps free that mind for further work. highdimensionman 16 4580 May 24, 2022 at 6:31 am
Last Post: highdimensionman
  Veridican Argument for the Existence of God The Veridican 14 5983 January 16, 2022 at 4:48 pm
Last Post: brewer
  Free Will Debate Alan V 82 24297 November 27, 2021 at 7:08 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  A 'proof' of God's existence - free will mrj 54 19053 August 9, 2020 at 10:25 am
Last Post: Sal



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)