what are we supposed to say again when christians ask us where we get our morality?

[Jenny A]

i think the christians have a point here

from what i can tell most atheists still get their morality from fear of the law or being publicly shamed, a lot of which was originally to do with religious intervention

an example would be murder

i can't really think of a reason not to murder everyone if there wasn't those consequences to it

And does the law or being shamed come from religion? The law is secular. so is social shame.