RE: brand new Thread:Simple mathematical error in quran.
June 26, 2010 at 2:34 pm
(This post was last modified: June 26, 2010 at 2:36 pm by mo3taz3nbar.)
my answer is so simple i dont know what you cant understand?
you are adding different situations to each other. the situation mentioned in the first of the verse is a man died having 2 daughters or more so your equation must be like this 2/3 + ? + ? = ? this is the situation mentioned what you are doing is adding unknowns which led to a situation not mentioned in the quran
about the avl thing i mentioned that in the Quran the general rules are given and if a situation is not mentioned its up to the ruler to decide what to do(taking in considiration the general rules)
NB according to islamic rules the parents get their shares first(if they exist) and what remains is given to rest of the familly members according to their shares so your calculations is pretty messed up from different ways
you are adding different situations to each other. the situation mentioned in the first of the verse is a man died having 2 daughters or more so your equation must be like this 2/3 + ? + ? = ? this is the situation mentioned what you are doing is adding unknowns which led to a situation not mentioned in the quran
about the avl thing i mentioned that in the Quran the general rules are given and if a situation is not mentioned its up to the ruler to decide what to do(taking in considiration the general rules)
NB according to islamic rules the parents get their shares first(if they exist) and what remains is given to rest of the familly members according to their shares so your calculations is pretty messed up from different ways
