RE: brand new Thread:Simple mathematical error in quran.
June 26, 2010 at 7:09 pm
(This post was last modified: June 26, 2010 at 7:10 pm by mo3taz3nbar.)
Quote:no it is not different situations...continue the verse and you will see the different situations given "...For parents, a sixth share of the inheritance to each, if the deceased left children; if no children, and the parents are the (only) heirs...."
the begining of the verse is talking about if he died and have 2 or more daughters this is the situation and what i quoted now is another situation as it says what the parents will take if he have children and if he dont have children you are adding all together
even in the situation you are saying(which is not mentioned in the Quran) you are making a mistake by not taking into consideration that the children share is from the remaining after parents take their share
Quote:are you saying one cant have a daughter, mother, father and wife at the same time???is that what you understood from my post?
Quote:dude even muslim people struggled to solve this mathematical error.they are using some constant(called avl) to fix that error(its not fixing it though you are not using exact percentages which god instructed.i gave you a link that contains about 60 different situations with no struggling and no avl(which i cant even know what it means) the struggling is just in your head and again i told you before that we are given the general rules and if there is a situation that is not mentioned the ruler have the right to decide what to do taking into consideration the general rules given in the Quran. i searched different situations but i cant find any problems if there is a certain situation you want to know about just write it and i will try to help you to understand
Quote:I have done the same discussion with Muslim Scholars. And they can't deny it. only saying we can fix this with avl constant.ok am not a muslim scholar and i answered you.you talking with a muslim scholar who dont know about this issue has nothing to do with our discussion unless you are using this to prove your point
Quote: I think your knowledge about islam (and mathematic) is very slight. so please "do some search"
no offence.
