Simple mathematical error in quran.

[annatar]

even in the situation you are saying(which is not mentioned in the Quran) you are making a mistake by not taking into consideration that the children share is from the remaining after parents take their share

once again you are showing that you are not reading. Read the verse, its clear that all percenteges are based on whole heritage. not remaining. read the verse carefully.Anyway its clear that you haven't done the math(or you are really bad at it.) becouse even if it said share remainings of heritage there would be lots of share not known whom to give.

ok am not a muslim scholar and i answered you.you talking with a muslim scholar who dont know about this issue has nothing to do with our discussion unless you are using this to prove your point Smile

i said "i discussed with a schollar and he didn't deny" becouse knew that problem. But you are unaware of this situation obviously. If you were aware.you wouldn't be talking like that.
By the way i haven't noticed that verse is following by another(nisa 11. and 12.) since i was depending on turkish versions of the verse. so rest of the instructions are there i'll edit my first post. My apologies for that..

I will try to explain this error more detailed. Perhaps you can understand now.(all quotations from quran.)

"But if there are [only] daughters, two or more, for them is two thirds of one's estate."

("..of one's estate" means from the whole of what you have left. just to make it clear.)
if there are more then 2 daughter they will get 2/3 of it.
lets say the guy had 3 daughters, -to make it easy lets assume 60$ he left- so girls are getting 40$ and 20$ left

"And for one's parents, to each one of them is a sixth of his estate if he left children."

(again ..of one's estate) it's declaring a condition "if he left children" it says which he has in our example.
father and mother are taking 1/6 each.

so we said 3 daughters so if mome and dad taking 1/6 of heritage they will take 10$ each

"But if you leave a child, then for them is an eighth of what you leave, after any bequest you [may have] made or debt."

(again he means from the whole of your heritage.)
if you have children 1/8 of what you have left is theirs(your wives)

so you have kids(daughters) father, mother and wifes and quran says if you have children you have to give your wives too that means 7.5 $ they will take.
so 3 girls=40$
mome+dad=20$
wives=7.5$
sum=67.5 which means %112 of your heritage.

it's all given in quran. all situations spesifically declared. I am just following quran!
percentages are little bit complicated in here maybe thats why muhammed messed up. he should had made it more simple( and fair )
before you answer, please read this example carefully and try to understand first. its not a difference of opinion it is a math error!! And for that it can be proved as easily as I did above. when you read and understand the mistake we can proceed to how muslims try to fix it(and how/why they fail)