Atheist simulator

[Smaug]

4) Theism means believing there is 1 or more gods. So there could be 1, 2, 3... And so on forever.

The probability of there being just one then is one in infinity. Which is zero. So there is zero chance that there is only one God, so any monotheism is wrong.

That's actually an improper argument because for the second statement to be true the first one has to imply that gods are represented by a uniformly distributed random variable (and a continious one to be exact). This isn't something one can prove.