Critical thinker, skeptical about atheism.

[JonDarbyXIII]

I made a few corrections to the OP:

Q- Where does the Universe come from?
Dogmatic atheist- We don't know, but isn't it great to try to find the answer
Theist- We don't know - it must have been some god. We can stop looking for answers now

Q Why are we here?
Dogmatic atheist- We don't know Maybe there is no 'reason.' But we can still make this like count in every way possible.
Theist- We don't know. But maybe there's a god that put us here to worship him.

Q Is there any meaning to life?
Dogmatic atheist- We don't know but as long as we're here, let's make the best of it and make it as meaningful as possible.
Theist- We don't know. Maybe there's something meaningful later after we die. [Therefore the meaning of life is... death]

Q Is there good and evil?
Dogmatic atheist (Dawkins)- There is no good and evil, we all dance to the tune of our DNA
Theist- Good and evil exist only as God tells me they exist, regardless of the good it does for people or the evils it perpetuates.

Why then do we put "evil" people in jails? ("evil" is a religious word)
A truly honest Dogmatic atheist- We don't put 'evil' people in jail. We put people who have committed crimes in jail.
Theist- The crimes committed by people in jail no longer matter if they are saved by God. [Or from the perspective of the people in jail: Friends, family and society may despise me for what I have done, but if I believe in a God, he can still love me.]