Did Yahweh Set Adam Up?

[Esquilax]

Didn't we go over this point already? School tests are something you study for, and are prepared for. Taken literally, A&E couldn't be prepared for this test because they didn't have knowledge of good and evil, and couldn't understand death in a world where nothing had died. Not to mention the fact that school teachers don't expel you for failing a test, and then bar your descendants from the school because you made one mistake.

Tell us where is the evidence they were not prepared, seems God would not have given them an rule if they were not prepared, they wouldn't even know they were give a rule if they were not prepared, nor would they know they would be punished. Seems to me you are being silly about this matter.

GC

Yeah, sorry, but your "it doesn't not say they were prepared!" fantasies aren't an argument; we're not obligated to take the most charitable possible interpretation of your book just because you'd like it if we did.