Ask a Traditional Catholic

[Randy Carson]

You have no chance of dismantling any of the arguments of the Catholic Church. We have been dealing with stupidity like yours for 2,000 years.

Actually you haven't. You've had Atheists only being able to speak up against you for about two hundred years, you've had socialists for about one hundred and LGBT (without the risk of being beheaded) and child abuse victims for about fifty. Doesn't it speak volumes that in the tiny space of time those four groups have had, all four have made the Catholic Church appear totally incompetent and have led to its influence upon Western Society evaporating?

I think it's not hard to tell which groups have the most compelling case. Even without the chance to fine tune the sophistry as you have it still makes a far more compelling case.

Rather than respond to ALL of the nonsense in your post, I'm going to direct you to a great article by Tim Staples which not only corrects your numerous errors regarding Mary and Joseph but utterly destroys James White at the same time.

Kind of a two-fer for me.

When Were Joseph and Mary Married?
By Tim Staples
http://www.catholic.com/blog/tim-staples...ry-married