What are you willing to do for Bryan Fischer?

[bennyboy]

Well, if the person is someone I hated enough to kill, then I'd kill him by not helping him. Because that's what not helping someone who is dying is-- passive killing.

[Zidneya]

I can already see the headlines Bryan Fischer saved by an atheist….although I still don't know if it will be seen as a good thing or a bad thing

[BrianSoddingBoru4]

Well, I've had a bit of first aid training, so I'd do what I could on spot, call an ambulance, stay with Fischer until the medics arrived, tell them what I've done, inform them I wish to be billed for all of Fischer's medical expenses - then I'd slip one of the medics $100 to blow Fischer on the way to the hospital.

Boru

[Cato]

I can already see the headlines Bryan Fischer saved by an atheist….although I still don't know if it will be seen as a good thing or a bad thing

You have issues.

[Zidneya]

[Sejanus]

[Zidneya]

Then you put it in Off Topic, not Philosophy, if you intended this as a kind of creative writing exercise.

Humor, terror, morality, creativity those are generated from one's life philosophies.

Like I said there aren't good or bad answers…...

No wait there are bad answers.

Anyone that finds this to be some sort of dilemma is an immoral cunt. Get the man medical attention for fuck's sake.

That is a complete bullshit "what if" and convoluted bullshit as well. If someone is not a direct physical threat to your life right at that second, and they are injured, and unarmed, you help them. PERIOD.

Nothing to ponder.

Independently even if people take it or not seriously what I'm not gonna stand for are those pussies that tell everyone else what they should or shouldn't answer.

What can't they say: I'll save him. But noooo they. There's only one answer and everyone else who thinks differently is wrong.

That's one of the ideas that started religion in the first place.

[Rev. Rye]

[vorlon13]

So maybe I fellate him while he lays dying ??

[Cato]

Nobody is suggesting that this Fischer character isn't a deplorable asshole, but I'm not in the habit of interrogating bloodied human speedbumps while on a stroll prior to getting them medical attention. No matter what his views are or the manner in which he disseminates them, I believe he can be countered without allowing him to writhe alone in pain until he succumbs to his injuries. I fear promoting Judge Dredd behavior by those with hypersensitivity to crankish opinions than I do to the crankish opinions themselves. The OP also doesn't consider the fact that if Fischer were to pass on the street that there will be some other asshole to immediately take his place.

Reciprocity is also in play. I would hope that somebody encountering my bloody mass would lend assistance without considering how my opinions mesh with their view of existence.