Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 16, 2026, 6:52 am

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
#41
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 6:41 pm)Belacqua Wrote:
(November 9, 2026 at 9:24 am)Angrboda Wrote: And the idea that Christianity plagiarizes prior religions has been repeatedly debunked.  It doesn't stop being propaganda simply because you are convinced it is true.

I agree with you that "plagiarizes" is the wrong word. That means significant portions of text copied without significant changes and left unattributed. But if Dao means that the Jesus story includes themes that occur in many other myths, that's true. 

The idea that a special person has a human mother and a god or God for a father is common in mythology. Achilles, Hercules, etc. And it's applied retroactively in hagiography of important historical figures. I suspect that in these cases people didn't believe it, but it was still customary.

The idea that the special person shows amazing ability at a young age. That's common in myth and also appears in the Jesus story.

And of course the idea that he gets killed and then comes back, that's not original. Most notably Dionysus, but others as well. 

I don't know if Dao is a native speaker of English or not -- perhaps he got the definition of "plagiarism" a bit wrong. 

It's also a matter of some debate whether the Evangelists intentionally copied elements from earlier myths. It seems like too much to be simply coincidence. 

There's a controversial theory that the Evangelists intentionally copied passages from Homer. I don't know how widely accepted this is. Here is a bit which I happily plagiarize from another source: "mimesis (a standard Greco-Roman literary practice of emulating and transforming famous ancestral texts)." So even if the mimesis was not direct, we know that ancient writers worked differently from modern historians, and happily mimicked older writing. 

I'm not sure what exactly you mean by "debunked" here. Is there a specific claim about the New Testament which was proposed and then shown to be false? If there are obvious parallels between the Jesus story and older ones, how is this propaganda?

Isn't there some MENSA group you can join and leave us alone and stop trying to wrangle in the new people who stop here.

Your smarter-than-thou only works on new people for a short time.
What fresh hell can this be? - Dorothy Parker
Reply
#42
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 6:41 pm)awty Wrote: Why does the general public need to be educated on the NT?

Believers perhaps, but not the general publicc.

Oh, and going to church on the regular doesn't make one a believer.

Because its teachings are unhealthy, for example. It teaches that the one who believes in Jesus will not be harmed by poison. It teaches that the death penalty should be given to children who rebel against their parents. It teaches that women should be silent. It teaches that the only good reason for a christian man to get married is because otherwise he will be destroyed by his urges. It teaches that you are unworthy of following Jesus if you do not give him all of your possessions. It teaches that you should leave wife and children behind for Jesus. It teaches that a man who feels some kind of lust when he sees a woman has committed adultery with her if she happens to be married. It teaches that god will give the one who prays anything that he asks for. It teaches that the whole of humanity will be divided and at war with each other over Jesus. It teaches that masturbation is a sin. It teaches that those who are not elected to pray for all eternity before god on his throne in heaven will instead be tormented in hell forever, god willing it so. 

It was not too long ago that my opinion was that there should be no education about religion whatsoever in schools. But after having educated myself better on the subject of christianity, I have changed my mind. Considering how extremely supported christianity is by the authorities, it is even more important.
Then the Pharisees and scribes asked Him, “Why walk not thy disciples according to the tradition of the elders, but eat bread with unwashed hands?” He answered and said unto them, “Well hath Isaiah prophesied of you hypocrites, as it is written: ‘This people honoreth Me with their lips, but their heart is far from Me. Therefore, in vain do they worship Me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.’ For laying aside the commandment of God, ye hold to the tradition of men, as the washing of pots and cups, and many other like things ye do.” And He said unto them, “Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition. For Moses said, ‘Honor thy father and thy mother,’ and, ‘Whoso curseth father or mother, let him die the death.’ (Mark 7:5-10)
Reply
#43
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 6:41 pm)Belacqua Wrote:
(November 9, 2026 at 9:24 am)Angrboda Wrote: And the idea that Christianity plagiarizes prior religions has been repeatedly debunked.  It doesn't stop being propaganda simply because you are convinced it is true.

I agree with you that "plagiarizes" is the wrong word. That means significant portions of text copied without significant changes and left unattributed. But if Dao means that the Jesus story includes themes that occur in many other myths, that's true. 

The idea that a special person has a human mother and a god or God for a father is common in mythology. Achilles, Hercules, etc. And it's applied retroactively in hagiography of important historical figures like Alexander and Julius Caesar. I suspect that in the latter cases people didn't believe it, but it was still customary.

The idea that the special person shows amazing ability at a young age. That's common in myth and also appears in the Jesus story.

And of course the idea that he gets killed and then comes back, that's not original. Most notably Dionysus, but others as well. 

I don't know if Dao is a native speaker of English or not -- perhaps he got the definition of "plagiarism" a bit wrong. 

It's also a matter of some debate whether the Evangelists intentionally copied elements from earlier myths. It seems like too much to be simply coincidence. 

There's a controversial theory that the Evangelists intentionally copied passages from Homer. I don't know how widely accepted this is. Here is a bit which I happily plagiarize from another source: "mimesis (a standard Greco-Roman literary practice of emulating and transforming famous ancestral texts)." So even if the mimesis was not direct, we know that ancient writers worked differently from modern historians, and happily mimicked older writing. 

I'm not sure what exactly you mean by "debunked" here. Is there a specific claim about the New Testament which was proposed and then shown to be false? If there are obvious parallels between the Jesus story and older ones, how is this propaganda?

While there are parallels between prior religious figures and those in the New Testament, anti-theists frequently exaggerate the wholesale nature of such similarities by misrepresenting elements of the prior religious stories. Misrepresented claims constitute propaganda rather than innocent scholarship. Also, as we see here, anti-theists depend upon representing a specific literalist strain of Christianity as prototypical of Christianity as a whole despite the less literalist origins of Christianity. In sum, the new friend who has been posting is adopting arguments and claims about Christianity which are uncharitable and exaggerate aspects of Christianity toward which he wishes to find fault.
[Image: extraordinarywoo-sig.jpg?rlkey=x1nmxbwrp...pouidnfvtl]
Reply
#44
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 7:02 pm)Dao Wrote:
(November 9, 2026 at 6:41 pm)awty Wrote: Why does the general public need to be educated on the NT?

Believers perhaps, but not the general publicc.

Oh, and going to church on the regular doesn't make one a believer.

Because its teachings are unhealthy, for example. It teaches that the one who believes in Jesus will not be harmed by poison. It teaches that the death penalty should be given to children who rebel against their parents. It teaches that women should be silent. It teaches that the only good reason for a christian man to get married is because otherwise he will be destroyed by his urges. It teaches that you are unworthy of following Jesus if you do not give him all of your possessions. It teaches that you should leave wife and children behind for Jesus. It teaches that a man who feels some kind of lust when he sees a woman has committed adultery with her if she happens to be married. It teaches that god will give the one who prays anything that he asks for. It teaches that the whole of humanity will be divided and at war with each other over Jesus. It teaches that masturbation is a sin. It teaches that those who are not elected to pray for all eternity before god on his throne in heaven will instead be tormented in hell forever, god willing it so. 

It was not too long ago that my opinion was that there should be no education about religion whatsoever in schools. But after having educated myself better on the subject of christianity, I have changed my mind. Considering how extremely supported christianity is by the authorities, it is even more important.

It is not the business of education to immunize citizens against the foolishness of religious beliefs that parents have freely chosen for their children. That's coercive and improper.
[Image: extraordinarywoo-sig.jpg?rlkey=x1nmxbwrp...pouidnfvtl]
Reply
#45
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 8, 2026 at 8:09 am)emjay Wrote:
(November 8, 2026 at 7:26 am)Belacqua Wrote: I'd never heard of Nicoli before, but some light Googling gives some idea. He appears to be in the circle of Jung, Ouspensky, and Gurdjieff. I know next to nothing about those latter two, but I suspect that whatever he writes won't be anything like traditional Christianity. 

Nicoli claims that the Bible, and apparently all sacred writing, has both an obvious meaning and an esoteric one, and of course he's the one to tell you what the deeper meaning really is. 

I'm sure you know it's an ancient idea -- that there's a surface meaning for regular people and a hidden one which can be revealed to initiates. That's pretty common in any ancient tradition, as far as I can tell. Like we all associate Taoism with the Tao Te Ching, which is paradoxical and Zen-like, but if you visit a Taoist temple in China chances are there will be paintings of hell in the outer lobby designed to scare people into behaving themselves. 

I think this sort of brings us back to things we were discussing earlier -- first, that the non-literal meanings have always been important to thinking people, and second, that these ancient traditions evolve, especially when they are adopted by a society where they aren't native. 

So I'm skeptical whether Nicoli is accurately portraying either Christianity or Buddhism in anything like their historical meaning. But even so he may have worthwhile things to tell us. 

It seems to me that the main, irreconcilable difference between Buddhism and Christianity lies in their approach to desire. As Dante makes very clear, the way to be a good Christian is to INCREASE your desire -- to love more passionately -- but to aim the desire in the proper direction. Whereas Buddhism aims at desire's extinction. 

If you do read the Nicoli I'd be interesting to hear his take on things.

Just to be clear, the guy who brought this up... a Buddhist in the group I go to... is not attacking Christianity in the slightest with this... quite the opposite it seems and the last sort of thing I expected... or wanted... to hear from a Buddhist... a leaning towards Christianity not away from it. Granted I know that in Buddhism you're supposed to be open towards all religion, but that's really hard for me, especially with Christianity Wink I don't want to read this sort of thing because I don't want it to essentially poison or sully my view of Buddhism. He actually reminds me a bit of you in his manner, so I'm surprised to see you saying you're skeptical of this 'Nicoll' author stuff... looks like it's gonna be me that has to read it first... not looking forward to it Wink But if I do, I'll try to let you know, as you ask, what his take is on things Smile

Just to say @Belacqua, I really think you might like that book I mentioned.... I'm 25% through it now, and it's just like talking to you Wink It's all about literalism vs non-literalism, your favourite subject Wink But it's actually quite interesting in its way... and frankly the non-literalist stuff in it makes more sense than the literal, which was not what I was expecting, nor was I expecting it to be being approached in a kind of logical way... I was expecting vagueness and poetry etc, but it's not that at all. It's talking about 'esoteric' stuff as if it's a well understood, and ancient non-literalist language (is it? is that what you speak of often?), rather than just the random musings of random individuals, which is what I was expecting, and its also talking about Plato et al, and 'being', knowledge', 'higher knowledge', and 'Good' etc... all the sort of stuff you talk about all the time.

So yeah, I really think you might like this book... its not about Buddhism at all, it's about Christianity, and claiming for instance that the word 'stone' means 'literal truth', in this 'esoteric' language, and 'water' means a higher understanding, and 'wine' an even higher understanding... so therefore that the water into wine miracle can be taken literally but can also, and better, be taken non-literally, representing the 'psychological' 'evolution' of people from 'low level' literal/sense based understanding to higher level 'spiritual' understanding... including describing that as what Jesus was going through, as a psychological rather than (or as well as) literal physical acts etc, development from human to spiritual. I didn't think I would find this so interesting but actually I am, despite it clearly looking down on literalists like me, just as much as you do (or might) Wink So yeah, I recommend it to you as something you might like. Granted I'm only 25% through it atm but I'm still curious to see why my Buddhist friend found this book so inspirational, so I'll keep reading, and hopefully talk to him about it next Buddhist meeting Smile
Reply
#46
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 7:27 pm)Angrboda Wrote:
(November 9, 2026 at 7:02 pm)Dao Wrote: Because its teachings are unhealthy, for example. It teaches that the one who believes in Jesus will not be harmed by poison. It teaches that the death penalty should be given to children who rebel against their parents. It teaches that women should be silent. It teaches that the only good reason for a christian man to get married is because otherwise he will be destroyed by his urges. It teaches that you are unworthy of following Jesus if you do not give him all of your possessions. It teaches that you should leave wife and children behind for Jesus. It teaches that a man who feels some kind of lust when he sees a woman has committed adultery with her if she happens to be married. It teaches that god will give the one who prays anything that he asks for. It teaches that the whole of humanity will be divided and at war with each other over Jesus. It teaches that masturbation is a sin. It teaches that those who are not elected to pray for all eternity before god on his throne in heaven will instead be tormented in hell forever, god willing it so. 

It was not too long ago that my opinion was that there should be no education about religion whatsoever in schools. But after having educated myself better on the subject of christianity, I have changed my mind. Considering how extremely supported christianity is by the authorities, it is even more important.

It is not the business of education to immunize citizens against the foolishness of religious beliefs that parents have freely chosen for their children.  That's coercive and improper.

But it is the business of high ranking professors on government pay to teach that the bible is the greatest literature ever written, and such. Ye ye... whatever.
Then the Pharisees and scribes asked Him, “Why walk not thy disciples according to the tradition of the elders, but eat bread with unwashed hands?” He answered and said unto them, “Well hath Isaiah prophesied of you hypocrites, as it is written: ‘This people honoreth Me with their lips, but their heart is far from Me. Therefore, in vain do they worship Me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.’ For laying aside the commandment of God, ye hold to the tradition of men, as the washing of pots and cups, and many other like things ye do.” And He said unto them, “Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition. For Moses said, ‘Honor thy father and thy mother,’ and, ‘Whoso curseth father or mother, let him die the death.’ (Mark 7:5-10)
Reply
#47
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 7:23 pm)Angrboda Wrote: While there are parallels between prior religious figures and those in the New Testament, anti-theists frequently exaggerate the wholesale nature of such similarities by misrepresenting elements of the prior religious stories.  Misrepresented claims constitute propaganda rather than innocent scholarship.  Also, as we see here, anti-theists depend upon representing a specific literalist strain of Christianity as prototypical of Christianity as a whole despite the less literalist origins of Christianity.  In sum, the new friend who has been posting is adopting arguments and claims about Christianity which are uncharitable and exaggerate aspects of Christianity toward which he wishes to find fault.

I very much agree with you that misrepresentation is bad, that most Christianity has been less literal than many believe, and that charitable arguments are good.
Reply
#48
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 7:44 pm)emjay Wrote: Just to say @Belacqua, I really think you might like that book I mentioned.... I'm 25% through it now, and it's just like talking to you Wink It's all about literalism vs non-literalism, your favourite subject Wink But it's actually quite interesting in its way... and frankly the non-literalist stuff in it makes more sense than the literal, which was not what I was expecting, nor was I expecting it to be being approached in a kind of logical way... I was expecting vagueness and poetry etc, but it's not that at all. It's talking about 'esoteric' stuff as if it's a well understood, and ancient non-literalist language (is it? is that what you speak of often?), rather than just the random musings of random individuals, which is what I was expecting, and its also talking about Plato et al, and 'being', knowledge', 'higher knowledge', and 'Good' etc... all the sort of stuff you talk about all the time.

So yeah, I really think you might like this book... its not about Buddhism at all, it's about Christianity, and claiming for instance that the word 'stone' means 'literal truth', in this 'esoteric' language, and 'water' means a higher understanding, and 'wine' an even higher understanding... so therefore that the water into wine miracle can be taken literally but can also, and better, be taken non-literally, representing the 'psychological' 'evolution' of people from 'low level' literal/sense based understanding to higher level 'spiritual' understanding... including describing that as what Jesus was going through, as a psychological rather than (or as well as) literal physical acts etc, development from human to spiritual. I didn't think I would find this so interesting but actually I am, despite it clearly looking down on literalists like me, just as much as you do (or might) Wink So yeah, I recommend it to you as something you might like. Granted I'm only 25% through it atm but I'm still curious to see why my Buddhist friend found this book so inspirational, so I'll keep reading, and hopefully talk to him about it next Buddhist meeting Smile

Uh-oh, you have found me out! Literally nothing I say on this forum is original. It's all standard for people who read this kind of book, and part of a tradition that goes way way back. 

So one of the obviously non-literal passages in the NT is where Jesus talks about throwing seeds around, and some will grow and some won't. And he's obviously talking about his preaching, which will reach some people and not others, but he preaches to everybody anyway. This is in contrast to a passage in Plato, where he says that if you have something important to say you should reserve it for special people who can understand, and you should cultivate such students the way a gardener protects a very special seedling. This has been taken as a hint that his most important ideas are protected and discerned by only a special few. 

So the reason Moses spent so long on top of the mountain is that he had to memorize, unwritten, lots of extra knowledge that will never be passed along to the uninitiated. 

And at the beginning of Plato's Timaeus, the first speaker is counting up to see if everybody's present, so the first words of the dialogue are "One, two, three..." This prompted one Neoplatonic philosopher to find a hidden message about number theory, and how numbers are intrinsically fundamental to the universe, etc. etc. I doubt very much that Plato had this in mind when he started the dialogue, but that doesn't mean it's worthless. 

I downloaded Nicoll's New Man just now from one of the usual e-book piracy sites, so I look forward to going through it. I wonder if he's sticking to the older traditions of esoteric interpretation, or doing new things. As I say, I don't know anything about Gurdjieff and Ouspensky, so I suspect a lot of that is new to me. 

Please let me know what your Buddhist friend thinks of it -- I wonder how much is compatible with traditional Buddhist thought.
Reply
#49
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 7:46 pm)Dao Wrote:
(November 9, 2026 at 7:27 pm)Angrboda Wrote: It is not the business of education to immunize citizens against the foolishness of religious beliefs that parents have freely chosen for their children.  That's coercive and improper.

But it is the business of high ranking professors on government pay to teach that the bible is the greatest literature ever written, and such. Ye ye... whatever.

Well, the Bible is certainly important as literature. You can't understand half of Western literature without it. 

That doesn't mean that those high-ranking professors teach it as true. In fact, given the trends in academia in the last few decades, I suspect that more professors are in agreement with you that Christianity is harmful and needs resistance.
Reply
#50
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
(November 9, 2026 at 6:37 pm)Dao Wrote:
(November 9, 2026 at 12:49 pm)BrianSoddingBoru4 Wrote: Not to mention (but I will anyway) that Dao is misusing the word ‘plagiarism’. Plagiarism is a deliberate act carried out with the intention to deceive. Similarities between the NT and older magic books are much more likely to be due to that fact that there are a limited number of religious proposition that appeal to people - good acts get you rewarded, bad acts get you punished, revere god(s), don’t kill people without cause, be kind/truthful/generous, and so on.

How-to books on the same subject are necessarily going to have similarities. There’s no call to drag in accusations of plagiarism.

Boru
I have not misused the word plagiarism. If you had any knowledge at all about the bible and its sources then you would see it plainly. The bible itself claims that every word of it is breathed out by God. If someone writes that, and also compiles the text from various stolen sources, without any mention of where he took them from, then it is exactly what you described as plagiarism, and with the claims that the bible makes it is as plagiaristic as it can possibly be. It is qualified plagiarism. What you say about meaning, god and people also makes no sense. You say that we are supposed to believe that it is a mere coincidence that Jesus said almost exactly the same as the Buddha, word for word. This is very well known also. But for some reason the general public is not taught anything that is worth knowing about what is supposed to be a fundamental text to their culture.

Nonsense.

And be kind enough to not presume what I do or don’t have knowledge of.

Boru
‘I can’t be having with this.’ - Esmeralda Weatherwax
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  The New Kilogram Is Here! The New Kilogram Is Here!! BrianSoddingBoru4 15 4703 May 21, 2019 at 2:09 pm
Last Post: BrianSoddingBoru4
  Supermathematics and Artificial General Intelligence ThoughtCurvature 28 12249 October 23, 2017 at 7:32 pm
Last Post: causal code
  The general wisdom is that Attention Deficit Hyperactivity plawnkhan 12 5521 October 10, 2015 at 8:03 am
Last Post: brewer
  Is science educantion enough Surgenator 18 5482 February 25, 2015 at 4:15 pm
Last Post: Chas
  General Info on Migraines thesummerqueen 2 1852 October 14, 2011 at 9:21 am
Last Post: thesummerqueen



Users browsing this thread: 8 Guest(s)