'Rate the above person's music'

[Tino]

edit: FOUL! Kayenneh posted while I was typing. She should know better.

8/10. Nicely reminiscent of The Ventures and the whole surf guitar thing.

Now that you've got me thinking about guitar, check out Speedy West

[Annik]

5/10 I have respect for this kind of music, but it isn't my favorite to listen to.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OzexP58si0w

[popeyespappy]

5/10 I could listen to it, but it isn't something I would play for myself.

[jonb]

Smoky clubs, shots of bourbon, dark and a place for the ones who don't fit to feel good about ourselves, I remember being one of the cats.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHmMrVPZf...re=related

[Tino]

8/10, great piece of music but best used as the background for a sad public service announcement.

[Gilgamesh]

3/10

Judging by what I've seen so far, my music taste is something you guys aren't fond of; likewise, I'm not liking what I've listened to so far. I foresee myself getting and giving a lot of low ratings in this thread.

I'm determined to get a decent rating on something English before I start posting Japanese stuff, though

Let's try Xandria, instead of Lunatica:

[Faith No More]

4/10. Sorry, but no decent rating this time.

[frankiej]

I enjoyed the bass... so, for that alone it gets a 6/10.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fj4VZ2Xa53g

[Angrboda]

Great idea for a thread. I became disenchanted with music threads when I started hosting my own Youtube videos, and found that many people were posting, but almost no one was listening. This brings that 'chantment back again. This makes other people's music exciting.

There's a suggested rule change after my video. Ignore if you feel like ignoring (to everyone, not nur Gilgamesh).

I give Bonammassa's Dislocated Boy 5/10 points. Joe, as usual, hits everything on the nines. And it's got body. But it reminds me too much of The Ballad Of John Henry to get any more than superficial acknowledgement. Ballad was a heart breaker. This is just testosterone drama queen.


This is not the greatest song of theirs, but it's what I have on endless repeat on my mp3 player currently.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvM7erkK720

The suggested rule change is to allow, in addition to posting the review of someone else's music above you, after everything else in your post, be allowed to add ratings for even earlier posted music. I adore that Tism track.

Shark jumping in advance of take home pay. Xandria. The music. The musical equivalent of a Draco in leather pants or Too Absurd To Fail. +2 points for that. Reminds me of some of Nightwish, but where Nightwish was epic, Xandria is just lugubrious. I've heard these same notes, in the same forms, and done so much better before this. I give it a 4/10. But then, I thought the same of the first Puffy Amiyumi CD I bought, and now I'm their biggest fan.

[Gilgamesh]

The suggested rule change is to allow, in addition to posting the review of someone else's music above you, after everything else in your post, be allowed to add ratings for even earlier posted music. I adore that Tism track.

Yes. Good idea. I will edit this into the original post.

Also, judging by the time stamps of the posts, I think you were ninja'd by Faith, Frankie.

Edit: Actually, editing the original post is impossible. You can only edit a post 120 minutes after it's been posted, apparently.