Would this be decent evidence for reincarnation?

[Zone]

While he didn't get quite all the details of his past life right it was a 90% hit rate there. I suppose you would need a few more samples to be sure it wasn't a lucky coincidence.

[Doubting Thomas]

I still have a hard time believing such a thing is possible. I have a hard time believing these kinds of documentaries to begin with because they're mainly concerned with sensationalism and rarely give a balanced view of the issue. Secondly, there's no way to tell whether or not these "memories" are being fed to the child so that he "remembers" them. Now if he mentioned the conditions of starving to death in Ethiopia from the time he was first able to talk, you might have a more compelling case. But a Scottish boy recounting life in another part of Scotland doesn't seem to be that impressive.

[Zone]

But a Scottish boy recounting life in another part of Scotland doesn't seem to be that impressive.

It's quite good because it's so bland, most adults tend to recall someone really dramatic or impressive in a past life like they're acting out some kind of a fantasy. A real case would be something fairly boring and normal. It could be you stay roughly in the same geographically location as well as there would be no need to traipse over from Africa or somewhere in your immaterial form or whatever it is. Though he described it as falling down a hole/portal so it sounds like you could instantly end up anywhere.

[downbeatplumb]

I recently changed my view on reincarnation.

There was a fly who seemed to await my approach and then take off just as i got to his position.

I came to the conclusion that it was a reincarnated bus driver.

[Brian37]

No. Reincarnation is superstitious bullshit just like any other.

[CapnAwesome]

I've watched a few programs on these claims and they never hold up to any sort of investigation. A large part of it is based on the total falsehood that Children somehow don't lie or make up things. Have these people never been around children? Children pretty much constantly make up things and it's easy to twist them around. If this was an adult nobody would take him seriously. Why does being a child make him more credible.

[Zone]

No. Reincarnation is superstitious bullshit just like any other.

It's technically possible though it doesn't have to be related to any specific religion, it could just be a part of the natural world we don't know anything about. If someone can prove they had a past life by providing details they shouldn't ought to know then it's worthy of interest. The boys information was good enough managed to locate his former house on the island and describe small details which is quite impressive. From what I know there are other cases like this one.

I've watched a few programs on these claims and they never hold up to any sort of investigation. A large part of it is based on the total falsehood that Children somehow don't lie or make up things. Have these people never been around children? Children pretty much constantly make up things and it's easy to twist them around. If this was an adult nobody would take him seriously. Why does being a child make him more credible.

How would he have been able to find out what he did and pass it off as a story about his former life? It was an remote obscure location and he mentioned some small details that match. So it's fairly good testimonial evidence.

[Brian37]

No. Reincarnation is superstitious bullshit just like any other.

It's technically possible though it doesn't have to be related to any specific religion, it could just be a part of the natural world we don't know anything about. If someone can prove they had a past life by providing details they shouldn't ought to know then it's worthy of interest. The boys information was good enough managed to locate his former house on the island and describe small details which is quite impressive. From what I know there are other cases like this one.

NO IT IS NOT

Organisms decay, the atoms that make up those organisms once broken up will not function AT ALL in the same manor as the organism it once was.

Reincarnation is bullshit, period.

[Zone]

NO IT IS NOT

Organisms decay, the atoms that make up those organisms once broken up will not function AT ALL in the same manor as the organism it once was.

Reincarnation is bullshit, period.

I don't think we know enough about consciousness to be able to say exactly what it is and how it's formed at this point. Anything you do want to say is a belief without evidence. Though something like this video a possible bit of evidence, something that was tested and to a good extent verified. He did get the car accident wrong but the house on an island in the Outer Hebrides he got right. This isn't a "Just believe it and it could be true" kind of thing if there's evidence.

There's some other interesting subjects of note that are worth a look. Telekinesis for instance, seen here operating under a glass bowl. This could be some kind of evidence of consciousness operating beyond the body to some tiny extent. This doesn't have to be anything supernatural at all just something we haven't covered yet.

[Anomalocaris]

I don't think we know enough about consciousness to be able to say exactly what it is and how it's formed at this point. Anything you do want to say is a belief without evidence. Though something like this video a possible bit of evidence, something that was tested and to a good extent verified. He did get the car accident wrong but the house on an island in the Outer Hebrides he got right. This isn't a "Just believe it and it could be true" kind of thing if there's evidence.

Is the alternative - totally new incorrigible fools are born every day - better than the theory of reincarnation, which suggests the same flock of fools returns time and again to screw with the world?