(December 18, 2015 at 7:22 pm)athrock Wrote: Cato, I agree with you to this point. I think the value of the Ontological Argument for the theist camp is that arguments such as this demonstrate that belief in a supreme being IS rational. That, in and of itself, is a blow to the notion that belief in god is irrational.
Are you intentionally misrepresenting me? I quite specifically stated that I disagreed with this conclusion and pointed out that the referenced article dismantled that part of Plantinga's claim.
Your quiver analogy is misplaced. Your effort is more similar to loading a trebuchet full of shit in the hope of getting some to stick.