RE: Animal rights, veganism and PETA
January 21, 2011 at 3:45 am
(This post was last modified: January 21, 2011 at 4:10 am by Violet.)
Doubtie Wrote:But it doesn't make it. So what if 'might' asserts 'right'? The point is it doesn't actually make it.
It makes it quite plainly, i think. Observe: if you don't think it's 'right' that I can claw my way into your country, killing all your women and children and annexing your former territory... this is what I have to say to you:
Doubtie Wrote:Yeah but since 'might' doesn't actually make 'right' at all, it's got nothing to do with morality. When we talk about 'might' we're talking about power, yes. But when we're talking about 'right' we're talking about morality.
When you talk about 'right' in such a manner, you've necessarily involked that something with enough power to consider the meaning of 'right' already exists. In other words, you literally cannot have morality without first having some degree of power. I would hardly accuse the rocks and trees of being moral or amoral
Jaysyn Wrote:Nowhere in my post did I equate intelligence with rights & if you can't understand the intrinsic difference between a pig & an infant, I ... I just don't have any words for that.
Let's glance at similarities shall we?
Pig: Poops whenever it has the urge to poop.
Infant: Poops whenever it has the urge to poop.
Pig: Makes a huge mess when it eats food.
Infant: Makes a huge mess when it eats food.
Pig: The domesticated variety only maintain their existence because of the work of their providers.
Infant: The domesticated variety only maintain their existence because of the work of their providers.
Enough similarities... now the differences:
Pig: Adult pig is much smarter than the human infant.
Pig: Adult pig sleeps much less than the human infant.
Pig: Adult pig will very likely provide resources to the human populace when it dies... infant is a gamble that could land anywhere between being a rocket scientist and being a bum, with the lesser intelligences probably favored.
Pig: Takes very little time out of each day to raise until butcher day... infant takes every moment it isn't sleeping and plenty of the times it is.
Pig: Can make a wonderful pet. Humans are illegal to turn into pets (though children are pets of sorts, insomuch as they are slaves of the master).
Pig: Squeal on occasion, but they get to stay outside much of the time, so you never have to listen to it. Infants cry like they are dying to multitudes of things, and it's really quite hard to figure out what it is they want when they are doing it, thus the crying persists and frustration levels increase.
Pig: Need i mention that the pig is a resource that consumes relatively few resources for what it is almost guaranteed to provide (a tasty meal)? Infants, well they consume and consume and consume and consume and will probably consume for many times the lifetime of that pig, and will also probably contribute to the overabundant population without actually doing anything worthy of note for their nation (let alone the human race, or planet).
Pig: People don't expect you to coddle them.. their lot in life is understood and pretty simple (growing machine of pork-flavored meat). Infants though... if you don't talk to them like they are a pet: people will look at you angrily and appear to be offended.
Pig: Will never crash your car, drain you some hundred-thousand dollars or more and then leave you for the world, will never date that jock whore you don't trust, wont run up your electricity and heating bill unless you are an idiot and are raising them through the winter and don't believe that the shelter you've provided for them is enough, won't buy 5,000$ worth of purchases in songs and movies or 10,000$+ in pursuit of video games. Infants: while they can't do any of these at this stage, this is a future they are very likely to have, plus several piles of money in doctor visits.
So far: i value pigs higher than i do human infants at this time. The chance of something positive coming out of your gamble with children is very low... and it is a chance, there is next to no certainty in it anywhere. Infants are entirely useless at that stage in their life... give them a number of years and they'll finally start putting out a little bit of what you've put in (granted, not much, and possibly never so much as a pig). The only thing to respect about infants is actually something tied to their caregivers (that they hold value in the infant enough to raise the infant). You can always eat the pig
Please give me a home where cloud buffalo roam
Where the dear and the strangers can play
Where sometimes is heard a discouraging word
But the skies are not stormy all day