RE: Scientific knowledge versus spiritual knowledge
January 7, 2016 at 9:23 pm
(This post was last modified: January 7, 2016 at 9:31 pm by Mystic.)
Ok I'm not going to quote cause I have hard time with that today.
You said how does it follow.
If a Creator can create morality/goodness out of nothing (a), then it can make it the case goodness/morality is such that it is good/moral to torture a innocent forever (b)
It cannot be that goodness/morality is such that it can be good/moral to torture an innocent being forever in any possible world (not b)
Therefore a Creator can't create goodness out nothing (not a)
There is a rule in logic.
A->B
Not B
Therefore Not A.
You said how does it follow.
If a Creator can create morality/goodness out of nothing (a), then it can make it the case goodness/morality is such that it is good/moral to torture a innocent forever (b)
It cannot be that goodness/morality is such that it can be good/moral to torture an innocent being forever in any possible world (not b)
Therefore a Creator can't create goodness out nothing (not a)
There is a rule in logic.
A->B
Not B
Therefore Not A.