Gay, Catholic and Doing Fine

[Brian37]

There is no "deal breaker"?

Ok, so when Hitler died all he had to do to get into heaven was say "oops, my bad"?

How sick.

That's not what I meant. What I meant is that we cannot determine a person's afterlife fate based on what they've done. It depends on the person's culpability while doing those things, and we do not know what a person's culpability is because we cannot read their minds.

Of course that's not what you meant. Once you swallow "god can do what he wants", you can move the goal posts to justify anything.

Nope sorry, your words were "no deal breaker". Make up your mind.

Now let me give you AGAIN, the real reason both you and I know Hitler was a monster.

Because humans  evolved with empathy. NOT A MAGIC BOOK.

Hitler succeeded because he bought the idea and sold the idea that Germans were God's master race. He was NO atheist. "Gott Min Uns" is on the NAZI belt buckles. And he quotes God in "Mien Kampf".

Nope sorry if you are going to claim "no deal breaker", then that leaves Hitler open for for forgiveness. And let me remind you your Bible has God killing off the Egyptian first born and causes a world wide flood, which can only be called by definition an act of genocide, I find it absurd to claim Hitler couldn't be forgiven, in terms of being logically consistent. So, if you rightfully condemn Hitler, why does god get to murder humans in mass unless we are merely his lab rats?

If nothing happens or cant happen that God does not want happening, then god wanted those 6 million Jews dead. If he has a reason for not stepping in, and that is part of his "plan", then the Holocaust was supposed to happen. 

Now again, I hate that fucker, he was a monster. But you fail to see once again, just like on the issue of gays, how bad logic leads you to justify anything you want, including ignoring your flawed logic.

AGAIN, just like the issue of gays, your old book does not explain in biological reasons why Hitler was a monster. Just like you cant understand why being gay is not a disorder. You are basing your morality on an old book.