Is God always "just"?

[Statler Waldorf]

---

A crime against a being with greater authority requires greater punishment.

Surely it was god who commited the first crime, because if he is supposedly omniscient then he would of realised that the vast majority of humanity would sin, and not only sin but refuse to believe in him.

Knowing this, god supposedly went ahead and created us anyway the oh so generous and loving god he is.
Only to KNOWINGLY send the vast majority of the human race down the fucking drain to hell, because he supposedly granted us 'freewill'. Well that's the come back you're going to give right? that it was US who CHOSE to go to hell?

Creating something and giving it freewill only to send it to hell, fully knowing that it will 'rebel' and 'sin', is not a get out clause for being a sadistic bastard.

It is cruel, sick, twisted, vile, arrogant and just plain wrong on oh so many levels.

---

Where does it say He granted us free will? That's nowhere in scripture. It also never says that God's purpose for creation was for the majority of men to "choose" to be saved. Not sure what God you think you are arguing against but it is not the God of the Bible.

---

---

Actually I don't think that, I know that. It's perfect logic. Something you guys seem to claim to practice with your mouths but never actually do with your minds.

This is why people like you should be watched closely. There isnt something clicking in your head that clicks in normal peoples heads. I am willing to bet this same mental deficiency is shared in extremist muslim brains as well. There is definitely an anti-social mode of thought going on here as well.

A crime against a being with greater authority requires greater punishment. Punch someone on the street and see what kind of punishment you get. Now, punch the President of the United States and see how much harsher your punishment is, and for good reason. He possesses more authority than the person on the street. God possesses infinite authority over man, so even one single crime against God (sin) is enough to justly merit eternal punishment. However, because he is not only just but also loving and gracious we all get far less than what we actually deserve. People whining about getting less punishment than they actually deserve is what is truly evil, not God.

There is one BIG, MAJOR difference...your god is imaginary...your imaginary freidn cant be slapped. So what we normal people really see in your post is that you think that paying back a slap with a nuclear bomb is not only plausable, but required. Waldork..PLEASE..go seek some help. You have a very bad problem and you need help man.

---

You are absolutely right, what is clicking in my head is certainly not clicking in yours. It's called logic. You made at least two logically fallacious arguments here (quite impressive considering how short your post was).

First, you resorted to ad hominem rather than duking it out on logical grounds.
Secondly, this discussion assumed God did exist if you read the original thread, so your second point is really just a red herring fallacy. Nice try though.